A Rentmeister Plumber

A Rentmeister Plumber earns strong scores across all four dimensions, driven by a large volume of reviews consistently praising honest pricing, same-day responsiveness, and skilled workmanship. The pricing dimension is a particular standout, with multiple reviewers citing savings of hundreds to over a thousand dollars compared to competitors, and several explicitly calling out the company's refusa... Read more

A Rentmeister Plumber earns strong scores across all four dimensions, driven by a large volume of reviews consistently praising honest pricing, same-day responsiveness, and skilled workmanship. The pricing dimension is a particular standout, with multiple reviewers citing savings of hundreds to over a thousand dollars compared to competitors, and several explicitly calling out the company's refusal to upsell unnecessarily. Professionalism scores are tempered slightly by one no-show incident (2015) and a 2016 review warning that the company had shifted toward price-gouging under younger staff replacing the semi-retired founder Larry. Project completion is well-supported, with reviewers describing jobs finished quickly, correctly, and with follow-through including post-job check-ins, though the one no-show and the noted misunderstandings in a 2023 review prevent a top-tier score. Experience scores are solid, with multiple reviewers describing technically competent problem-solving, including a notable case where the technician correctly identified a cleanout plug approach that a competitor had missed entirely. Read less