Find Nearby Plumbers In Chicago, Illinois

Preferred Professional Plumbing earns a strong WW Score driven by an exceptionally large and consistent body of reviews across all four dimensions. Professionalism is the most frequently cited strength, with dozens of reviewers explicitly praising punctuality, communication, friendliness, and responsiveness — including same-day and weekend service. Project completion scores are high, with reviewers consistently noting jobs were finished correctly, on time, and with thorough follow-through including callbacks and multi-visit projects. Experience is well-documented through specific technical praise: reviewers highlight Grant's 17 years of licensure, creative problem-solving (e.g., sourcing a special Grohe tool, negotiating warranty replacements), and quality craftsmanship on complex jobs like gas lines, sewer re-piping, and tankless water heater installation. Pricing scores slightly lower than other dimensions due to one reviewer noting the cost felt high for a simple job, though the overwhelming majority describe pricing as fair, reasonable, or cheaper than competitors.

• Three reviews appear to be near-identical duplicates of the same detailed water heater/tankless installation review, all dated 2023-12-15 — this may indicate a copy-paste submission error or platform duplication rather than fraud, but these were counted as a single unique review for scoring purposes.
• Two reviews appear to be identical duplicates of the same kitchen sink/ice maker review (one dated 2024-06-09 and one dated 2024-02-10) — treated as a single unique review for scoring purposes.
• Two reviews appear to be identical duplicates of the same 'diagnosed problem swiftly' review (one dated 2024-06-09 and one dated 2024-05-25) — treated as a single unique review for scoring purposes.
• Five reviews contain no text (only a star rating) and were excluded from dimensional scoring as they provide no usable evidence.
• One 1-star review (2025-02-09) contains no text, making it impossible to assess the nature of the complaint. This is a minor flag as it cannot be evaluated or addressed.
• A significant portion of reviews (roughly 25+) are dated 2024-06-09 with no specific timestamps, which may suggest a batch import or platform migration artifact rather than organic review timing. This does not appear to indicate fake reviews given the specificity and variety of content.
• The vast majority of reviews are 5-star. While the volume and specificity of content largely supports authenticity, the near-absence of critical feedback should be noted as a mild caution for prospective customers.
• Approximately 20 reviews predate 2023 and carry reduced recency weight. However, the contractor maintains strong recent review volume through mid-2025, suggesting consistent performance over time.

This WW Score is highly reliable — it is based on a large volume of detailed, specific, and largely recent reviews across all four scored dimensions, with sufficient mention counts to assign HIGH confidence to every dimension.

Loyal Handyman demonstrates exceptional performance across all four dimensions with consistently high marks. Professionalism is a standout strength, with 72 reviews explicitly praising punctuality, responsiveness, communication, and courteous demeanor—John and his team arrive on time, respond quickly to inquiries, and maintain professional conduct throughout. Project completion is equally robust, with 78 reviews confirming jobs are finished completely, efficiently, and often faster than expected, with follow-through on callbacks and commitments. Pricing receives strong validation from 35 reviews citing fair, reasonable, and transparent quotes with no hidden charges—customers frequently note competitive pricing relative to market alternatives. Experience is well-documented across 58 reviews, with customers highlighting skilled workmanship, problem-solving ability, attention to detail, and the ability to handle complex or challenging tasks. The overwhelming majority of reviews are from the past 12 months (75+ reviews), indicating current, reliable performance.

• All 80 reviews are 5-star or 4-star ratings with only 2 four-star reviews; no negative reviews present. While the consistency is impressive, the absence of any critical feedback or lower ratings is unusual and warrants noting, though the specificity and detail in reviews suggests authenticity rather than fake reviews.
• Two reviews mention different handyman names (Zhandos vs John), suggesting either multiple team members or name variations, but this does not undermine data quality.
• One review (2024-08-24) explicitly mentions a minor cleanliness issue (leaving old installer materials on floor), reducing that rating to 4 stars—this is the only explicit complaint in the dataset and was appropriately reflected in the rating.

This WW Score of 91.2 is highly reliable, supported by 80 recent reviews (75+ from past 12 months) with consistent, detailed, and specific praise across all four dimensions. The HIGH confidence across all dimensions reflects strong mention counts (35–78 per dimension) and the specificity of customer feedback, which demonstrates authentic experiences rather than generic praise.

A&Y Plumbing, led primarily by Juan, receives overwhelmingly positive feedback across all four scored dimensions from a large and diverse review base spanning 2020 through 2024. Professionalism is the most frequently cited strength, with dozens of reviewers explicitly praising punctuality, responsiveness, clear communication, respectfulness, and cleanliness — including mask and shoe-cover protocols. Pricing is consistently described as fair, reasonable, and transparent, with multiple reviewers specifically noting that Juan honored original quotes even when jobs ran longer or grew more complex than anticipated. Project completion scores are very high, with reviewers repeatedly confirming that jobs were finished fully, callbacks were honored, and follow-through was consistent across both small and large jobs. Experience and technical skill are well-documented, with reviewers citing Juan's diagnostic ability, camera scoping, knowledge of code compliance, and willingness to explain his work in detail — including one notable case where he identified a gas leak and out-of-code piping that other plumbers had missed.

• All 82 reviews are 5-star ratings (one is 4-star), which is statistically unusual for a contractor with this volume of reviews. However, the reviews contain highly specific job details, named individuals, varied writing styles, and unique scenarios — this significantly reduces the likelihood of coordinated fake reviews.
• A large portion of reviews (approximately 45 of 82) predate January 2024, with the bulk concentrated in 2020–2022. Only a handful of reviews are from the past 12 months (2024). Scores are weighted toward the more recent reviews but the older volume still contributes meaningfully to confidence.
• No negative reviews or critical feedback of any kind were present in the dataset. While this may reflect genuinely excellent service, it also means there is no data on how the business handles complaints, disputes, or failed jobs — a limitation worth noting.

This WW Score carries HIGH reliability due to the large volume of reviews, extensive specific detail across all dimensions, consistent patterns over multiple years, and no detectable signs of coordinated fake review activity — though the near-total absence of any critical feedback and the recency gap (few 2024 reviews) are minor limiting factors.

Ben at Principle Plumbing earns consistently strong marks across all four dimensions based on a large and detailed review set spanning nearly a decade. Professionalism is the most frequently cited strength, with reviewers repeatedly praising his punctuality, clear communication, responsiveness to emergencies, and courteous demeanor — the single 1-star review citing a 48-hour non-response is a notable outlier that modestly tempers this score. Pricing is described as fair, transparent, and competitive across more than half the reviews, with multiple customers explicitly noting he came in below competing quotes and never added surprise charges. Project completion is well-documented, with jobs consistently described as finished correctly, on time, and with cleanup included, and no reviews citing abandoned or incomplete work. Experience scores are also high, with numerous reviewers highlighting Ben's diagnostic skill, problem-solving ability, and technical knowledge across a wide variety of plumbing tasks.

• One 1-star review (2021-05-19) describes a 48-hour non-response after being asked to text details — this is a legitimate negative data point and was factored into the professionalism score.
• The review set is heavily skewed toward 5-star ratings (39 out of 40), which warrants mild scrutiny. However, the reviews contain specific job details, named equipment, unique scenarios, and varied writing styles, which strongly suggests authentic reviews rather than fabricated ones.
• Approximately 15 reviews are older than 3 years (pre-2022), with the oldest dating to 2014. While these support a long track record, more recent reviews (2022–2024) were weighted more heavily. The most recent reviews (2023–2024) remain consistently positive, suggesting no meaningful quality decline.
• Only 3 reviews are dated within the past 12 months (2023–2024), which limits recency confidence slightly, though those reviews are fully consistent with the historical pattern.

This WW Score is highly reliable — it is based on 40 reviews with rich, specific detail across all four scored dimensions, consistent patterns over multiple years, no signs of fake review activity, and only one negative data point that was appropriately incorporated into scoring.

Joe and R&R Plumbing receive consistently strong marks across all four dimensions from all 8 reviewers. Professionalism is a standout theme — every review mentions same-day or prompt responsiveness, clear communication, polite demeanor, and thorough explanations of work performed. Pricing transparency is explicitly praised in at least 5 reviews, with multiple customers noting competitive quotes, no hidden charges, and receipts provided for materials. Project completion is excellent across the board, with reviewers highlighting that jobs were finished fully and correctly the same day, including complex situations that prior plumbers had failed to resolve. Experience and technical skill are repeatedly validated — Joe identified a shutoff valve others missed, fixed a spigot without opening drywall, and resolved a sewer backup in under two minutes that two other companies could not fix.

• All 8 reviews are 5-star ratings with no negative or mixed feedback — this warrants mild scrutiny, though the reviews contain specific job details, unique scenarios, and varied writing styles that reduce the likelihood of fabrication.
• No reviews older than 12 months from the most recent review date (2024-10-30), so recency weighting is uniformly positive and no older reviews needed to be discounted.
• Sample size of 8 reviews is relatively small; scores carry HIGH confidence per dimension due to mention counts, but the overall profile would benefit from a larger review base to fully validate these results.

This WW Score is reasonably trustworthy given that all 8 reviews are recent (within 13 months), contain specific and varied details, and cover all four scored dimensions consistently — however, the small total review count and perfect 5-star uniformity mean the score should be treated as a strong early signal rather than a fully validated long-term track record.

Andres Plumbing Services receives consistently strong marks across all four scored dimensions, with professionalism being the most frequently and enthusiastically cited quality — nearly every reviewer mentioned punctuality, responsiveness, clear communication, and courteous demeanor. Pricing transparency and value were highlighted in a large majority of reviews, with multiple customers explicitly noting that Andres was the most competitive quote they received and that he honored his estimates without upselling. Project completion is also very well supported, with reviewers describing same-day or next-day service, jobs finished completely, and follow-up guarantees honored. Experience and workmanship were praised in roughly half the reviews, with specific mentions of problem-solving ability, technical knowledge, and high-quality results. The overall picture is of a highly reliable, customer-focused plumber with a strong track record across a meaningful volume of reviews.

• All 20 reviews are 5-star ratings with no negative or mixed feedback, which warrants mild scrutiny. However, the reviews contain specific job details, varied phrasing, unique scenarios, and named tasks (wax rings, garbage disposals, drain rerouting, faucet replacements, etc.), which significantly reduces the likelihood of fabrication.
• Several reviews are older than 12 months (2022–2023), but the majority of reviews (12 of 20) are from 2024, providing strong recency support. Older reviews are consistent in tone and detail with recent ones.
• No negative reviews or constructive criticism are present in the dataset. While this may reflect genuine quality, it also means there is no data on how Andres handles complaints, difficult jobs, or disputes.

This WW Score is based on 20 reviews with strong specificity, good recency, and consistent detail across all four dimensions, making it a HIGH confidence assessment that can be reasonably trusted as an accurate reflection of this contractor's performance.