Allen's Plumbing has a large and deeply mixed review history spanning over a decade. Professionalism scores moderately well overall — the majority of reviews praise individual technicians (JP, Bennett, Tarin, Justin, Jonah, Davin, Daniel, etc.) as courteous, knowledgeable, and professional, but a meaningful minority of reviews describe serious failures including no-shows, rescheduling without noti...
Read more Score Narrative
Allen's Plumbing has a large and deeply mixed review history spanning over a decade. Professionalism scores moderately well overall — the majority of reviews praise individual technicians (JP, Bennett, Tarin, Justin, Jonah, Davin, Daniel, etc.) as courteous, knowledgeable, and professional, but a meaningful minority of reviews describe serious failures including no-shows, rescheduling without notice, rude dispatchers, and at least one incident of a technician starting a fire and another leaving hazardous waste on a client's floor. Pricing is the weakest dimension: multiple reviewers explicitly called out charges as excessive or shocking (e.g., $1,050 labor quote for a faucet/disposal install, $2,150 for a water heater, $600 for a 20-minute wax ring job, $423 for a wrong diagnosis), and several noted hidden trip/diagnostic charges not disclosed upfront, though a handful praised fair or competitive pricing. Project completion is mixed — many jobs were completed well and on time, but recurring complaints about no-shows, rescheduled appointments, unfinished work, and at least one case of a job left incomplete for weeks drag the score down significantly. Experience scores highest among the four dimensions, with many reviewers specifically praising technical skill and problem-solving, though a few reviews describe botched repairs, wrong diagnoses, and damage caused by technicians.
Flags & Warnings
• DUPLICATE REVIEWS DETECTED: Two pairs of reviews appear to be exact duplicates — the 'Justin arrived in a timely manner' review (5-star) appears on both 2025-06-06 and 2025-06-04, and the long 'second Yelp review for Allen's Plumbing' (5-star) also appears on both dates. These duplicates were counted only once each for scoring purposes.
• BLANK REVIEWS: Approximately 18 reviews contain no text at all (only a star rating). These were excluded from dimension scoring as they provide no usable qualitative data.
• POTENTIAL GEOGRAPHIC INCONSISTENCY: Several reviews appear to reference locations outside Hawaii (Idaho Falls, Pennsylvania, Florida, Tennessee, St. Petersburg, Lehigh Valley) which may indicate this listing aggregates reviews from multiple businesses or a different Allen's Plumbing entity. Scores from clearly off-island reviews were still included but noted as potentially belonging to a different business.
• RECENCY NOTE: Reviews span from 2011 to 2025. A significant number of negative reviews regarding scheduling failures, rude dispatchers, and billing disputes date from 2016–2022. More recent reviews (2024–2025) trend more positively for technician quality but pricing complaints persist into 2025.
• SERIOUS INCIDENT FLAGS: One review (2024-01-24) alleges a technician started a fire between walls causing $10,000 in damage. One review (2021-09-07) describes hazardous waste left on a child's bedroom floor. One review (2019-03-08) alleges a bill of over $550 with no receipt and disputed charges. One review (2024-09-03) describes a $423 charge for a completely wrong diagnosis with management refusing to refund. These are serious quality and ethics concerns that weigh heavily on scoring.
• PRICING TRANSPARENCY CONCERN: Multiple independent reviewers across different years describe undisclosed trip/diagnostic charges, quotes that changed dramatically on-site, and pressure to accept additional services. This is a recurring pattern, not isolated incidents.
• ONE REVIEW (2024-05-13) gives 5 stars but the text is entirely negative ('Don't believe Allen's commercial on TV. He doesn't care about his customers'). This review's star rating was disregarded as inconsistent with its content; the text was used for qualitative scoring only.
Reliability Statement
This WW Score is based on a large volume of reviews (196 total, 172 with usable data) spanning over a decade, giving it HIGH statistical confidence, but the score should be interpreted cautiously given the wide variance in experiences, credible reports of serious incidents, persistent pricing transparency complaints, recurring scheduling failures, and possible geographic data contamination from reviews that may belong to a different Allen's Plumbing entity outside Hawaii.
Read less