McCarthy Plumbing

McCarthy Plumbing demonstrates strong professionalism and technical skill, with consistent praise for punctuality, friendliness, and workmanship quality across 58 and 35 mentions respectively. However, the company is significantly hampered by pricing concerns (71.0 score), with multiple customers reporting unexpected travel time charges, hourly rate inconsistencies, and perceived overcharging rela... Read more

McCarthy Plumbing demonstrates strong professionalism and technical skill, with consistent praise for punctuality, friendliness, and workmanship quality across 58 and 35 mentions respectively. However, the company is significantly hampered by pricing concerns (71.0 score), with multiple customers reporting unexpected travel time charges, hourly rate inconsistencies, and perceived overcharging relative to work performed. Project completion shows moderate strength (79.5) but is undermined by several documented failures including incomplete repairs requiring multiple callbacks, warranty disputes, and quality issues in new construction work. The company exhibits a polarized reputation: long-term customers and recent reviews are highly positive, but recurring complaints about billing practices and occasional service failures create meaningful trust gaps. Read less