American Eagle Plumbing

American Eagle Plumbing scores strongly on professionalism, project completion, and experience, with the vast majority of reviewers praising punctuality, clear communication, thorough workmanship, and same-day or next-day responsiveness across a wide range of plumbing jobs. The experience dimension is bolstered by multiple reviewers noting technical depth, problem-solving ability, and even third-p... Read more

American Eagle Plumbing scores strongly on professionalism, project completion, and experience, with the vast majority of reviewers praising punctuality, clear communication, thorough workmanship, and same-day or next-day responsiveness across a wide range of plumbing jobs. The experience dimension is bolstered by multiple reviewers noting technical depth, problem-solving ability, and even third-party plumbers complimenting the quality of prior installations. However, the pricing dimension is meaningfully dragged down by a recurring pattern of overcharging complaints — at least five separate reviews across multiple years explicitly describe being billed far above expectations or market rates, with one reviewer calculating over $350/hour per plumber and another noting a 60% premium over competing bids. These are not isolated incidents and span from 2017 through 2025, indicating a persistent pricing concern rather than a one-off. Two blank reviews with 5-star ratings were excluded from scoring as they contained no usable content. Read less