Get a Toilet Installation Quote Now!
Rather talk with someone? Call Us Directly

Toilets get replaced for a handful of reasons: a hairline crack in the tank or bowl, a base that rocks and won’t stay sealed, a fixture that needs plunging every week, or a 3.5-gallon-per-flush relic from before 1994 that wastes more water than the whole rest of the bathroom. Homeowners in Columbus also swap them during a remodel or to move up to a comfort-height model.

Before buying anything, measure the rough-in: the distance from the finished wall (not the baseboard) to the center of the floor bolts. About 85% of homes are 12 inches, but houses built before 1970 often run 10 or 14. Get that number wrong, and the toilet physically won’t fit. Then measure from the wall to the nearest obstacle in front. Round bowls run 28 to 30 inches deep, elongated 30 to 32, and the extra two inches has stopped plenty of bathroom doors from closing.

A standard replacement runs $350 to $800 all in, with labor at $150 to $450 and the toilet itself $100 to $1,000. Most plumbers in Columbus finish in one to two hours and bill a service minimum. What pushes the number up is what’s under the old fixture: a corroded flange adds $145 to $300, a seized shut-off valve $50 to $150, and a soft subfloor $200 to $600. Wall-mounted and upflush models cost considerably more.

The reason to hire a licensed plumber comes down to the wax ring. It has to seat perfectly on the first try, and a bad seal leaks into the subfloor for months before anything shows. Below you’ll find licensed plumbers handling toilet installation in Columbus and replacement, flange and valve repair, haul-away, and relocations. Compare licensing, reviews, and rates, and have your rough-in measurement ready when you call.

List of Toilet Installation Companies In Columbus

Based on our criteria
Workman Score
68.4 /100
Based on
8 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp
Score Data Quality
Limited evidence
Use with caution
  • Project Completion 78%
  • Professionalism 62%
  • Experience 70%
  • Price-friendly 45%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

R&T Yoder presents a deeply mixed picture across reviews. Professionalism is the most-mentioned dimension and is significantly dragged down by two serious negative reviews — one describing a technician as disrespectful, allegedly racist, and physically dangerous (driving recklessly), and another citing poor customer service and deceptive practices. Positive reviews do highlight courteous and profe... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile
Workman Score
62.1 /100
Based on
4 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp
Score Data Quality
Limited evidence
Use with caution
  • Project Completion 58%
  • Professionalism 52%
  • Experience 72%
  • Price-friendly 78%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

Professionalism is the most-mentioned dimension and is significantly dragged down by a detailed 1-star review describing a complete no-show with no communication, which directly contradicts the positive experiences described in other reviews. Project completion is similarly mixed — one reviewer never had their job started at all, while others report fast and effective service. Pricing and experien... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile
Workman Score
58.3 /100
Based on
261 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp Angi Angi Thumbtack Thumbtack Homeadvisor Homeadvisor Google Google
Score Data Quality
Strong evidence
High confidence data
  • Project Completion 52%
  • Professionalism 68%
  • Experience 60%
  • Price-friendly 28%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

Peterman Brothers presents a deeply polarized review profile. Individual technicians are frequently praised for professionalism, friendliness, punctuality, and clear communication, which elevates the professionalism score considerably. However, pricing is the single most damaging dimension: dozens of negative reviews describe charges that reviewers characterize as grossly excessive, non-transparen... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile
ROOTER MAN

ROOTER MAN

Columbus, Indiana
Workman Score
58.2 /100
Based on
752 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp Angi Angi Thumbtack Thumbtack Homeadvisor Homeadvisor Google Google
Score Data Quality
Strong evidence
High confidence data
  • Project Completion 60%
  • Professionalism 62%
  • Experience 63%
  • Price-friendly 32%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

This is a franchise brand with hundreds of locations, and the review pool reflects wildly inconsistent quality across different operators and technicians. Professionalism scores are dragged down significantly by a large volume of reviews describing rude, condescending, or outright hostile technicians and office staff, though many positive reviews praise specific named technicians as courteous and ... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile
Workman Score
58.7 /100
Based on
9 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp
Score Data Quality
Moderate evidence
Decent data coverage
  • Project Completion 52%
  • Professionalism 55%
  • Experience 55%
  • Price-friendly 72%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

C Lacey Plumbing presents a deeply mixed picture across all dimensions. Professionalism is significantly undermined by multiple explicit no-show, no-call complaints spanning different years, which directly contradict the positive reviews praising punctuality and courteous behavior. Project completion is similarly split — while several reviewers report successful, thorough work, one detailed 1-star... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile
Workman Score
58.3 /100
Based on
11 reviews analyzed
Yelp Yelp Angi Angi
Score Data Quality
Moderate evidence
Decent data coverage
  • Project Completion 52%
  • Professionalism 62%
  • Experience 65%
  • Price-friendly 78%

What is the overall customer analysis in August?

Proficient Plumbing presents a deeply mixed picture. Several positive reviews praise professionalism, politeness, and reasonable pricing, but two detailed 1-star reviews — one of which appears to be a near-duplicate submission — describe serious failures: a botched water heater installation with unresolved follow-up, the owner hanging up on a customer seeking warranty repairs, and a subcontractor ... Read more
Score last updated August 2026
View Profile

How much does toilet installation cost?

A standard replacement runs $350 to $800, including the toilet and labor, with many homeowners paying $400 to $900 once haul-away and supplies are counted. Labor alone is $150 to $450. Toilets themselves start near $100 and reach $1,500 or more for smart models. Prices sit in these ranges, though major metros run 30% to 50% higher. Add $145 to $300 if the flange needs replacing, and $50 to $200 for removing and hauling the old one away.

How do I know which toilet will fit?

Measure the rough-in first: wall to the center of the rear floor bolts, from the finished wall rather than the baseboard. Most homes are 12 inches; older ones run 10 or 14, and those need a model made for that size. Next, measure wall to the nearest obstacle. Round bowls need 28 to 30 inches, elongated 30 to 32. You also want 15 inches of clearance on each side. Plumbers verify all of this before ordering.

How long does toilet installation take?

One to two hours for a straightforward replacement using existing plumbing, the plumber shuts off the water, drains, and removes the old unit, sets a new wax ring, positions the toilet, reconnects the supply, and tests for leaks. Add time if the flange is damaged, the shut-off valve is seized, or the floor needs leveling. Most plumbers price this as a small fixed job with a service minimum rather than pure hourly. Relocating a toilet takes far longer.

Can I install a toilet myself?

It’s possible and saves $200 to $400 in labor, but it’s one of the riskier DIY calls. The wax ring has to seat perfectly on the first attempt; no second chances without a new ring, and a bad seal leaks into the subfloor invisibly. Overtightening tank bolts cracks porcelain. Toilets weigh 70 to 120 pounds, so plan on a second person. If you find a damaged flange midway through, you’re calling a plumber for a half-disassembled job anyway.

When should I replace a toilet instead of repairing it?

Replace it if the tank or bowl is cracked, the base rocks after the bolts are tightened, or the fixture predates 1994 and uses 3.5 gallons per flush. Chronic clogging in a single toilet also points to a worn trapway. Repair first when the toilet runs constantly or won’t fill a flapper or fill valve costs $15 and takes minutes. Ask a plumber to diagnose before you spend on a replacement. Many utilities offer rebates for replacing pre-1994 models.

Do I need a permit to replace a toilet?

Usually not for a like-for-like swap that reuses the existing flange and supply line; most jurisdictions treat it as a fixture replacement. A permit is likely if you’re moving the toilet, which means altering the drain and vent, or adding a toilet where none existed. Wall-mounted models with in-wall carriers may also trigger one. Check with the local building department before starting, and let your plumber pull whatever the job requires. Unpermitted work can surface during a home sale.

Should I choose comfort height or standard?

Comfort height, 17 to 19 inches to the seat versus 14 to 16 for standard, is easier on knees and hips and matches ADA-range seating. It costs nothing extra and removes a likely future replacement, which is why most adults choose it. Standard height suits households with small children better. Elongated bowls are more comfortable but add about two inches of depth. Confirm the door clears before ordering; plumbers check this routinely. It’s the most commonly skipped step.

Other Related Plumbing Services in Columbus

Search made easy

Search your nearby area for the service man

24/7 customer support

Search your nearby area for the service man

Make a confident choice

Search your nearby area for the service man

1.2 million + Plumber reviews analyzed

See customer stories
IR
Igal Rubinshtein @igal

Joel and his team went above and beyond to make sure they helped us fix the gas leak. Joel is a man of his word and came through on his promise.

AP
Alex Pritchard @alexpritch

Very expensive. Make sure you establish the price up front. They did some work on gas pipes, which was specialized so the prices weren't so horrible.

JS
Joe S. @joe

They did a good job and came quickly. Installed a bidet in my toilet. Shout out to Casey for the quality work.

DE
D Evonne W. @evonne

Scheduled service for a clogged toilet and never showed. No call, all messages unanswered

JA
Jari @jari22

If its an easy fit sure they maybe great but if its something different then quoted they are going to charge you either way a hefty price.

AU
Ashley Undercuffler @undercuffler

They never called my property manager, or myself, to ask if they could do an additional estimate while at my property. I was shocked. Companies cannot go around doing estimates.

AJ
A Jackson @jacksona

Mike showed up in an hour to shut off a spigot that I could not shut off. Always great friendly service at a reasonable price!!!

IR
Igal Rubinshtein @igal

Joel and his team went above and beyond to make sure they helped us fix the gas leak. Joel is a man of his word and came through on his promise.

AP
Alex Pritchard @alexpritch

Very expensive. Make sure you establish the price up front. They did some work on gas pipes, which was specialized so the prices weren't so horrible.

JS
Joe S. @joe

They did a good job and came quickly. Installed a bidet in my toilet. Shout out to Casey for the quality work.

DE
D Evonne W. @evonne

Scheduled service for a clogged toilet and never showed. No call, all messages unanswered

JA
Jari @jari22

If its an easy fit sure they maybe great but if its something different then quoted they are going to charge you either way a hefty price.

AU
Ashley Undercuffler @undercuffler

They never called my property manager, or myself, to ask if they could do an additional estimate while at my property. I was shocked. Companies cannot go around doing estimates.

AJ
A Jackson @jacksona

Mike showed up in an hour to shut off a spigot that I could not shut off. Always great friendly service at a reasonable price!!!

What does the Wise Workman score mean?
<70 Low
71–80 Moderate
81–100 High
77.5
WW Score
Learn more about how the Wise Workman scoring system works, along with our data governance policy.
What things affect the Wise Workman score?
Price-Friendly
💰Professionalism:
Experience
🛠️Project
Completion

Want a quote from ?