All Star Plumbing earns strong marks across all four dimensions, with professionalism being the most frequently cited strength — dozens of reviews praise punctuality, courtesy, communication, and responsiveness including after-hours and emergency availability. Experience and workmanship are consistently highlighted across a wide range of job types including full repiping, sewer line replacement, w...
Read more Score Narrative
All Star Plumbing earns strong marks across all four dimensions, with professionalism being the most frequently cited strength — dozens of reviews praise punctuality, courtesy, communication, and responsiveness including after-hours and emergency availability. Experience and workmanship are consistently highlighted across a wide range of job types including full repiping, sewer line replacement, water heater installs, and emergency leak repairs. Project completion is generally strong, with most reviewers reporting jobs finished on time and to satisfaction, though two negative reviews specifically cite a failed callback after a new water heater began leaking and a pattern of missed appointments — these meaningfully drag the completion score down. Pricing is viewed favorably by most reviewers, with several explicitly noting All Star beat competitor quotes, though one 2-star review alleged a significantly inflated estimate and one 1-star review described a $2,000+ quote for a water heater installation as predatory, introducing meaningful downward pressure on the pricing score.
Flags & Warnings
• Seven reviews contain no text at all (labeled 'unknown' or blank) and were excluded from dimension scoring — they contribute only to total review count.
• The majority of highly positive reviews share similar phrasing patterns (prompt, courteous, professional, knowledgeable) which is common for genuine reviews in this industry but warrants mild caution.
• Two 1-star reviews and two 2-star reviews raise specific concerns: one describes a leaking water heater with no follow-up from the company, one describes repeated missed appointments and poor responsiveness from Jennifer, one alleges a technician lied about a shut-off valve to manufacture an emergency upsell, and one describes a $2,000+ water heater quote as predatory — these are credible negative signals and are factored into scoring.
• A significant portion of reviews (roughly 20+) are dated 2024-06-09 with identical timestamps, suggesting possible batch import or platform migration rather than organic posting — this does not necessarily indicate fake reviews but reduces confidence in the date accuracy of those entries.
• Many reviews are older than 3 years (2013–2021 range), which limits their relevance to current service quality. Recent reviews (2024–2025) are more heavily weighted in scoring.
• One review references 'All Stay Plumbing' and another 'All Start' — likely typos for the same company, treated as valid reviews.
Reliability Statement
This WW Score is based on a substantial volume of reviews with usable content and carries HIGH overall confidence, but should be interpreted with awareness that a small cluster of credible negative reviews — particularly around follow-through, appointment reliability, and one alleged upsell — indicate the company is not without meaningful service failures.
Read less